And that should be the first indicator how not to go about dining; with a super hyped-up expectation. My two traveling companions were more skeptical and, thus, nothing was surprising to them.
Star Noodle is located off the highway, almost in seclusion but with plenty of parking space. We got there at 6 pm and were not the first to be hovering around the front door. As expected, we were told our wait would be around an hour or so. Thus, we wandered off after putting our name down but still returned within the half hour. We got our table shortly after and although we had doubts whether the hostess knew how to properly do her job, we were pleased with the service from our server.
This modernized Asian noodle bar reminds me of a lot of contemporary restaurants found everywhere in Thailand with a similar concept; an interpretation of what's modern in composition, flavours and texture. For me, I find simplicity and unpretending good taste get lost in all the glitz and glam.
I guess what I was hoping in finding at Star Noodle was something that exemplifies strong, bold flavours, using local and traditional Asian ingredients. Something special or unique that will keep drawing me back. We ordered about 5 items on the menu.
I saw the picture of hapa ramen, $12, everywhere on review websites. When I tried it, it was by far incomparable to ramen in Vancouver. The miso broth was not rich, as many had claimed. The house-made noodles were good, but the broth and the meat made this ramen subpar. The barbecued pork were nothing short of food court quality. It was dry, was not well marinaded, and not charred and smoky; just extremely average.
Leilani's On the Beach
We tried our luck at Leilani's On the Beach, overlooking the beautiful Kaatalani beach.
Starting off with Chef's raw bar platter for $13.95, ahi poke and shrimp ceviche arrived in smaller portions that what we expected.
The fish taco at Leilani's was voted Maui's Best by Maui Time magazine. At $14.95, I sunk my teeth into the succulent, cajun-rubbed grilled fish topped with chilies, grated cheese, salsa, and cabbage. It was pretty satisfying.
But the most satisfying item was the ginormous Kimo's Original Hula Pie. At $7.95, this dessert is a must-try when you are in Lahaina. Due to its sheer size, it's best to share this dessert. I dug in starting at the tip of the pie, scooping out creamy macadamia ice cream. At the bottom was dark chocolate cookie crust; thick, yet crumbly like Oreo crust. Of course, I didn't forget the rich chocolate fudge dripping down the pie, more grinded nuts, and light fluffy whip cream. I swear, this giant piece of treat is to-die-for.
Fish Market Maui
The Fish Market was the most low profile place we visited and it turned out to be best find in our whole trip! A fish market and a fast food join all in one, you can bet the seafood here is fresh. Don't be expecting a great atmosphere though, it is a fish market after all.
We feasted on this giant seared ahi tuna steak sandwich for $13.99 with a bag of chips and coleslaw. This was the winner. I love ahi tuna club sandwich, but I've never seen a tuna steak this big and thick before. It was seared perfectly, and rare in the centre, you'd have to be a fish love to enjoy this. It was juicy and succulent and well-seasoned. The fact it was accompanied by caramelized onion, cabbage, tomatoes with wasabi aioli on fluffy onion bun also made the biggest difference in the world.
You're not in Hawaii until you get a grilled mahi mahi. Served with rice, pasta salad, this was a very simple and modest dish. Nonetheless, the fish was perfection; flakey, plump and tender.